Advanced Search
8

Cranberry and urinary tract infections.

Guay DR

Drugs. 2009; 69(7):775-807

8 Must Read

Raul Raz, Technion School of Medicine, Haemek Medical Center, Israel. F1000 Urology

09 Jun 2009 | Changes Clinical Practice, Confirmation, Review

Changes clinical practice - I agree with the author of this article that cranberry should no longer be considered as an efficient prophylaxis for recurrent urinary tract infections (UTIs).

"Cranberry products cannot be recommended for the prophylaxis of recurrent UTIs at this time." This is a very important and significant conclusion of an excellent paper reviewing data regarding the new strategies in preventing recurrent UTIs in women.

During the last few years, cranberry has been described as an efficient prophylaxis for recurrent UTIs. However, currently, due to the heterogeneity of clinical study designs and the lack of consensus regarding the dosage regimen and formulation, clinical practice should be changed accordingly. Here, the author writes an excellent paper summarizing the issue of new strategies to prevent recurrent UTIs in women. This article provides new contribution to the field by presenting evidence and conclusions regarding cranberry use as prophylaxis for recurrent UTIs. According to this article, since there is no consensus regarding dose regimen and formulation, cranberry should no longer be considered as an efficient prophylaxis for UTIs.

Acknowledgements: I would like to thank Hana Edelstein for their assistance in the preparation of this evaluation.

Competing interests: No potential interests relevant to this article were reported.

Raz R: ""Cranberry products cannot be recommended for the prophylaxis of recurrent UTIs at this time..." Evaluation of: [Guay DR. Cranberry and urinary tract infections. Drugs. 2009; 69(7):775-807; doi: 10.2165/00003495-200969070-00002]. Faculty of 1000, 09 Jun 2009. F1000.com/1159865#eval621292

Short form
Raz R: 2009. F1000.com/1159865#eval621292

Faculty of 1000 evaluations, dissents and comments for [Guay DR. Cranberry and urinary tract infections. Drugs. 2009; 69(7):775-807; doi: 10.2165/00003495-200969070-00002]. Faculty of 1000, 09 Jun 2009. F1000.com/1159865

Short form
Faculty of 1000: 2009. F1000.com/1159865

Only signed-in users with full subscription access can make comments.
Sign in/get access to leave a comment.

No comments yet.

Urinary tract infection (UTI) refers to the presence of clinical signs and symptoms arising from the genitourinary tract plus the presence of one or more micro-organisms in the urine exceeding a threshold value for significance (ranges from 102 to 103 colony-forming units/mL). Infections are localized to the bladder (cystitis), renal parenchyma (pyelonephritis) or prostate (acute or chronic bacterial prostatitis). Single UTI episodes are very common, especially in adult women where there is a 50-fold predominance compared with adult men. In addition, recurrent UTIs are also common, occurring in up to one-third of women after first-episode UTIs. Recurrences requiring intervention are usually defined as two or more episodes over 6 months or three or more episodes over 1 year (this definition applies only to young women with acute uncomplicated UTIs). A cornerstone of prevention of UTI recurrence has been the use of low-dose once-daily or post-coital antimicrobials; however, much interest has surrounded non-antimicrobial-based approaches undergoing investigation such as use of probiotics, vaccines, oligosaccharide inhibitors of bacterial adherence and colonization, and bacterial interference with immunoreactive extracts of Escherichia coli. Local (intravaginal) estrogen therapy has had mixed results to date. Cranberry products in a variety of formulations have also undergone extensive evaluation over several decades in the management of UTIs. At present, there is no evidence that cranberry can be used to treat UTIs. Hence, the focus has been on its use as a preventative strategy. Cranberry has been effective in vitro and in vivo in animals for the prevention of UTI. Cranberry appears to work by inhibiting the adhesion of type I and P-fimbriated uropathogens (e.g. uropathogenic E. coli) to the uroepithelium, thus impairing colonization and subsequent infection. The isolation of the component(s) of cranberry with this activity has been a daunting task, considering the hundreds of compounds found in the fruit and its juice derivatives. Reasonable evidence suggests that the anthocyanidin/proanthocyanidin moieties are potent antiadhesion compounds. However, problems still exist with standardization of cranberry products, which makes it extremely difficult to compare products or extrapolate results. Unfortunately, most clinical trials have had design deficiencies and none have evaluated specific key cranberry-derived compounds considered likely to be active moieties (e.g. proanthocyanidins). In general, the preventive efficacy of cranberry has been variable and modest at best. Meta-analyses have established that recurrence rates over 1 year are reduced approximately 35% in young to middle-aged women. The efficacy of cranberry in other groups (i.e. elderly, paediatric patients, those with neurogenic bladder, those with chronic indwelling urinary catheters) is questionable. Withdrawal rates have been quite high (up to 55%), suggesting that these products may not be acceptable over long periods. Adverse events include gastrointestinal intolerance, weight gain (due to the excessive calorie load) and drug-cranberry interactions (due to the inhibitory effect of flavonoids on cytochrome P450-mediated drug metabolism). The findings of the Cochrane Collaboration support the potential use of cranberry products in the prophylaxis of recurrent UTIs in young and middle-aged women. However, in light of the heterogeneity of clinical study designs and the lack of consensus regarding the dosage regimen and formulation to use, cranberry products cannot be recommended for the prophylaxis of recurrent UTIs at this time.

DOI: 10.2165/00003495-200969070-00002

PMID: 19441868

Export